That was the operator’s response to a request for more specific wording in a consequential loss clause.
The contract was for fishing services: a specialised contractor, hired on a call-off basis to retrieve equipment from a well. It already contained the familiar language: exclusion of “all” indirect and consequential losses, loss of profit, business interruption, loss of use, loss of contracts, and so on.
The contractor’s legal counsel wanted very specific wording added: rig downtime and spread costs, including the costs of other contractors and subcontractors, were also to be excluded.
The operator said no.
Consider a fishing contractor coming on site to take equipment out of the well. Rig downtime may already be happening. The rig is waiting for the fishing contractor to do its job. If things do not go well, the costs continue to accumulate. That very common, very generic clause now has a very practical role to fulfill. What does it actually cover?
There was another moving part: the governing law of this contract was French law. The contractor needed clarity on whether rig downtime was excluded, rather than a future lawsuit debating whether it counted as consequential loss under French law.
The adviser insisted that rig downtime be spelled out. Written down in the clause.
The operator ultimately agreed.
That is one of the most important things a contract professional can do: sit beforehand and think about the relevant losses that the two parties may see differently.
What is consequential loss, exactly?
It is very hard to imagine contractual terms and conditions in upstream oil and gas—for services, supply, drilling and associated services—without a consequential loss clause. A familiar industry approach is for the parties to exclude liability for specified losses suffered by the other, often in the form of a reciprocal indemnity.
Depending on the contract, the parties may choose a very simple, very short and concise clause. Sometimes they go for something long and detailed. But familiarity with the heading does not explain what the parties have actually agreed to exclude.
Contract forms illustrate the point. One major oilfield services company’s purchase-order form lists business interruption and losses of profits, revenue, use of assets and contracts. An international operator’s oilfield-services form goes into more detail, including deferral of production, addressing foreseeability and expressly keeping termination fees outside the definition. Another operator’s template for drilling rental tools, equipment and services refers to specified categories whether the losses are direct or indirect, together with reciprocal group indemnities. FIDIC Silver Book wording separately identifies certain losses alongside indirect or consequential loss.
The words are doing different work in these examples. Some name the loss. Some also address whether it is direct or indirect. Others preserve a particular type of payment from the exclusion. The same heading does not mean the same protection. The relevant edition and the wording of the actual contract still need to be checked.
One of the main moving parts in identifying what is consequential loss, and what is not, is the wording of the actual clause. The governing law will also have a profound impact on how that wording is interpreted, understood and disputed.
Under English law, the traditional distinction between direct and consequential loss comes from the two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale. It is not simply a distinction between the first thing that went wrong and everything that happened afterwards. Nor is every loss of profit necessarily consequential. The wording, the contract and the circumstances matter.
But is a dispute really the right moment to find out whether a particular loss falls within the exclusion the parties thought they had agreed?
Finding out has to be done onshore, while the contract is being negotiated: identify the losses, agree which are to be excluded and put that agreement into precise contractual wording.
Transocean and Providence: the breach did not settle the spread-costs question
The dispute between Transocean and Providence is a useful illustration of why this matters.
Providence hired Transocean’s rig to drill an appraisal well. Problems with the rig interrupted operations. While the rig was unable to perform, Providence incurred wasted costs for other contractors’ personnel, equipment and services—the spread costs.
The High Court found Transocean in breach and initially allowed Providence to recover spread costs by set-off. Transocean appealed the spread-costs issue, arguing that the agreed exclusion covered those costs.
In 2016, the Court of Appeal agreed with Transocean. The detailed definition extended to the use or cost of use of property, equipment, materials and services supplied by contractors, subcontractors and third parties. Read in its contractual context, it covered the spread costs claimed.
Freedom of contract matters here, as do the words the parties choose. The fact that a party has breached its obligations does not, by itself, make an agreed exclusion disappear. The Court of Appeal gave effect to this exclusion; it did not decide that every clause labelled “consequential loss” automatically excludes spread costs.
Parties can spend a great deal of time arguing whether a loss is consequential, indirect or absolutely direct and derives from the breach. Where the intention is to exclude a particular category, the drafting should express that intention clearly.
“You caused me downtime.”
Back to the fishing contractor.
One party can say: “It is a direct loss because, hey, you caused me downtime. It derives directly from your breach of the contract.”
The other party can say: "These are exactly the losses the clause was supposed to exclude."
Same event. Same contract. Very different expectations.
That is why "it’s all here already" was not enough in the fishing contract. The relevant loss needed to be written down, so the contractor would not have to rely on winning that argument later.
Reviewing a consequential loss clause means looking at the work itself. What very specific losses could arise if a contractor breaches its obligations, or when things simply do not go well enough?
Which of those losses could one party see as consequential, while the other says they arise directly from breach, lack of quality or poor equipment?
Each loss needs to be assessed separately. The parties can then agree, transparently, which losses will be excluded and which will remain potentially recoverable, subject to the other terms of the contract and the applicable law. The definition, the exclusion and any supporting indemnity need to be read together. They should express the same agreement.
That is the critical part of working with a consequential loss clause.
Before accepting "it’s all here in the contract clause already," can both parties point to the wording that deals with the actual loss they have in mind?
For more on exclusion clauses for consequential and indirect damages, read: