← All Insights Risk allocation cannot be scattered knowledge. Contract risk allocation in upstream oil and gas, Vermeulens
Risk Allocation

Risk Allocation Cannot Be Scattered Knowledge

Olga Labai, Of Counsel / Senior Legal Counsel · 10 November 2026 · 9 min read

Why every upstream business needs a Contract Risk Allocation Procedure

Across all the materials I have published about upstream contracting, the clauses change but the underlying problem rarely does.

It appears when parties use a Master Service Agreement without properly implementing it. It appears in a battle of the forms, when the purchase order says one thing and the supplier’s quotation says another. It appears when negotiations stall because neither side can explain why a provision is genuinely necessary beyond saying that it is “standard”. It appears when a company announces that it “does not negotiate its terms and conditions”, as though repetition could turn an unsuitable position into a sensible one. It appears in consequential-loss exclusions, governing law debates, contractual discrepancies and post-Macondo indemnities.

The recurring problem does not lie in weak drafting. It is that the organisation has not made an institutional decision about risk.

The position may exist somewhere. It may be held in the memory of an experienced lawyer. It may be reflected imperfectly in a contract template inherited from a previous project. It may sit inside the insurance programme, the HSE management system or an approval matrix. It may be understood by one company director and contradicted by another.

But if the position has not been brought together, tested and approved as an organisational standard, and clearly formulated as the company’s policy and procedure, it is not yet a system. It remains scattered knowledge.

In upstream oil and gas, scattered knowledge is an expensive way to contract.

The contract is where the business model meets the risk

Upstream contracts do not merely record a price and a scope. They decide who carries the financial consequences when people are injured, equipment is damaged, a well is lost, pollution occurs, the host government revokes the field licence, production is delayed, confidential information escapes, intellectual property is challenged or a contractor fails to perform.

Those consequences cannot be allocated intelligently by reading the indemnity clause in isolation.

The allocation is spread across the contract: scope, warranties, performance standards, remedies, liquidated damages, indemnities, liability caps, exclusions, insurance, suspension, termination, title, risk of loss and the obligations imposed on subcontractors. The clauses across all of the project’s contracts operate as one system, whether the parties manage them as one or not.

Industry model contracts also reflect this deliberate architecture. IADC’s offshore forms expressly recognise that drilling and associated operations create risks of injury, property damage, well loss, pollution, loss of well control and reservoir damage, and that the parties’ compensation is agreed against the contractual allocation of those risks. Lawyers know that a “simple” knock-for-knock provision is a critical risk-management tool.

This is the industry’s accumulated contracting knowledge. Yet many businesses still re-open the same foundational questions whenever a new contract arrives.

That is why a Contract Risk Allocation (CRA) Procedure is essential.

The procedure comes before procurement

Contracting does not begin when procurement issues a tender. It begins earlier, when the business decides:

A Contract Risk Allocation Procedure records those decisions and turns them into an operating framework.

The procedure is not a list of contract clauses. It is not another procurement workflow explaining how to conduct a sound tender and award a contract. It is the organisation’s approved position on contractual exposure and the authority for applying that position.

That distinction matters. A procurement procedure may tell a contract engineer that three approvals are required. A CRA Procedure tells the contract engineer what is being approved, why the proposed allocation is outside the norm and who is sufficiently senior, and sufficiently informed, to accept the exposure.

Without it, an approval may confirm that a document travelled through the correct electronic workflow while saying very little about whether the business should have accepted the risk inside it.

The experience of the company that rents out critical safety equipment: the value was not the document alone

Recently, I learnt what happened after a company offering safety-critical equipment for rent implemented its contract risk allocation procedure for revenue-generating contracts.

The important point was not that this business had produced another corporate document. The improvement came from the detailed process of deciding and implementing the company’s position.

This company provides well-control equipment and services in a sector of the industry where the technical importance of the work can be entirely disproportionate to the value of an individual contract. A supplier of safety-critical equipment needs to understand precisely what it controls, what it does not control, what its insurers will support, what responsibilities properly belong with the operator after the equipment is transferred and where a client’s proposed contract moves beyond a commercially sustainable position.

Creating the procedure required the business to examine its own operations more closely: its service lines, equipment, personnel, HSE responsibilities, insurance, contractual interfaces and approval authority. That exercise made the company’s contracting position more consistent and helped the people negotiating contracts understand why the position existed.

This is one of the less obvious benefits of a CRA Procedure. It not only improves contracts; it also forces an organisation to understand itself. It ultimately helps the business to understand when to walk away from apparently attractive opportunities with dignity, not because performing the contract would be difficult or impossible, but because the terms and conditions offered by the client fall far outside the business’s “safe operating zone”.

When a business cannot agree its position on pollution, well control, consequential loss, damage to its equipment, third-party exposure or intellectual property, the disagreement may reveal more than a drafting problem. It may expose uncertainty about the service being sold, the operational controls behind it, the insurance purchased for it or the level of risk the business is genuinely prepared to finance.

The procedure brings those questions into the open before the live negotiation makes them urgent.

It replaces personal preference with organisational authority

Many contract negotiations are slower than they need to be because the parties are negotiating from personal positions rather than approved business positions.

One lawyer considers a clause acceptable. Another lawyer rejects it. A procurement professional remembers that the company accepted similar wording two years ago. The project team says mobilisation is urgent. Management sees the contract value but not the uncapped exposure. The supplier is told the terms are non-negotiable, although the same terms were amended for another supplier last month.

This cannot be cured through contractual “discipline”, because it is institutional inconsistency revealed during negotiation.

A properly implemented CRA Procedure changes the conversation. Instead of saying, “I do not like this clause”, the negotiator can say:

The discussion becomes less personal and more commercial.

It also gives procurement and commercial teams a more authoritative role. They do not need to become lawyers. They do need to understand the commercial effect of the positions they take to market, recognise material departures and know when specialist legal, insurance, technical or HSE input is required.

Legal expertise is then used where it adds the greatest value, not as a substitute for the business having a position of its own.

It makes flexibility controlled, not accidental

A CRA Procedure is sometimes misunderstood as an attempt to impose one set of terms on every transaction. It should do the opposite.

The procedure establishes a baseline and then defines the circumstances in which departure may be justified.

An operator buying routine equipment does not face the same risk as an operator procuring drilling or well-intervention services. A contractor supplying equipment only does not have the same exposure as a contractor whose personnel install, operate or maintain it at the wellsite. A company may be the contractor in its client-facing agreements and the purchaser in its subcontracts. It may therefore need different procedures, or clearly separated sections, for revenue-generating and procurement contracts.

Market conditions also matter. So do the project stage, the urgency of the requirement, the availability of alternative suppliers, the technical criticality of the service, the contract value, insurance limits and the potential business upside.

The procedure makes judgment visible.

That is the difference between a controlled exception and an accidental concession hidden in a redline or given as an “emergency exception”.

It connects the parts of the organisation that already own the risk

Contractual risk is not owned by legal alone.

The business defines its appetite. Technical teams understand operational control. HSE understands safety-critical interfaces. Insurance confirms whether the promised indemnity is funded. Procurement takes the position to market. Legal tests drafting and enforceability. Finance and credit assess the counterparty and balance-sheet consequence. Contract owners carry the obligations into performance. Management approves departures.

The CRA Procedure connects all of those functions.

That connection is particularly important because an indemnity on paper is not necessarily protection. A party may accept liability it cannot insure, cannot price and could not pay if the risk materialised. Transferring such a risk may produce an impressive clause and a fragile project.

Nor should every department review every clause in every contract. A good procedure tells the organisation when additional expertise is required. It distinguishes the standard position from the exceptional one and ordinary approvals from exposures that need senior management attention.

The objective is not more bureaucracy. It is fewer surprises.

The procedure must reach the live contract

The most beautifully drafted CRA Procedure is useless if it remains in a folder.

Its principles must appear in the organisation’s templates, tender instructions, bid-review tools, approval forms, negotiation guidance, insurance requirements and contract-handover process. Departures must be recorded. The signed allocation must be communicated to the people performing the contract. Experience from claims, negotiations and completed projects must be fed back into the standard position.

The organisation should be able to answer five practical questions:

  1. What is our approved position?
  2. Does it fit this transaction, scope and operating context?
  3. Who may approve a departure?
  4. Where is the decision recorded?
  5. What must operations know after signature?

If the organisation cannot answer those questions, it may have a policy but it does not yet have contractual control.

What the experience has shown

Numerous examples from my practice (from working on drilling campaigns, implementing MSAs and eliminating battles of the forms to experiencing stalled negotiations, drafting industry model contracts and studying the impact of Macondo) all lead to the same conclusion.

Upstream businesses do not usually suffer from a complete absence of contract knowledge. They suffer because the knowledge is fragmented, unevenly distributed and applied too late.

A Contract Risk Allocation Procedure brings that knowledge into one organisational decision-making system. It tells the business what “normal” looks like. It identifies what is excessive. It preserves room for justified commercial decisions. It prevents urgency from becoming authority. It gives procurement and commercial teams a reliable mandate. It allows legal, insurance, HSE and technical specialists to intervene at the right point. And it creates a learning loop through which the organisation’s contracts improve over time.

The industry already understands the principle: risk should sit with the party best able to control, insure and manage it.

The procedure is how a business stops repeating that principle in presentations and starts applying it consistently in contracts.

An upstream business without a Contract Risk Allocation Procedure is still allocating risk. It is simply doing so contract by contract, negotiator by negotiator and emergency by emergency.

That is not flexibility.

It is firefighting. And it creates significantly greater risk.

Read more about aspects of upstream oil and gas contracting:

Insights | Vermeulens